Pie In The Park
Easy as Pie and Sweeter the Second Time
Pie in the Park 2025 – Report
Now in its second year, Pie in the Park returned to Forestville Downtown Oaks Park, one of the town’s two privately owned community gathering places. Since its preservation in 2013 by the Forestville Planning Association (soon to be renamed the Forestville Partnership Alliance), the park has become a hub of local life. On this warm summer day, it buzzed with laughter, music, and the irresistible aroma of homemade and bakery pies. Once again, Forestville came together to celebrate neighborly spirit, local connections, and the sweetest traditions.
Forestville Downtown Oaks Park sits on land long cherished by Indigenous people of the region, for whom the oak groves hold deep cultural and spiritual significance.
The festivities unfolded around three main attractions.
The Pie Walk offered a playful twist on the classic cakewalk, with participants circling for the chance to win a whole pie. Steve Wharton accompanied on banjo, and the excitement was contagious as participants and volunteers joined in singing “I Only Have Pies for You,” a whimsical nod to the Flamingos’ classic. Pie Walk coordinator Vikki Miller recalled a heartwarming moment: a man leapt into the air when he won a bakery pie for his family. His wife and young child shared his joy, their laughter echoing through the park.
Another favorite was the Pie Share. Jacque Brazieal, last year’s Hometown Hero, and her dream team handed out more than 750 slices of pie. Bakers were encouraged to bring a pie to share with the community and, in return, sample another’s creation. The result was a table brimming with flavors and a spirit of generosity that defines small-town Forestville. FPA President Lucy Hardcastle expressed her gratitude: “Thanks to the volunteers and talented chefs in the community who donated their time and love to share delicious pies.”
Miller also thanked the bakeries that contributed 67 pies to the Pie Walk, adding: “A special thank you goes out to the Trappe family, George Gonzalez, and our sponsors. The Trappes were the event’s largest donors, and patriarch Wendel filled the dunk tank with water and Jonathan and Gonzalez brought all of the ice. Community donations also filled 20 raffle baskets, adding to the fun.
The Pie Contest, led by Brittany Carpenter, showcased the best of Forestville’s home bakers. First place went to Vicki Holden for her Lemon Meringue Pie; second to Ethan Loudon’s Key Lime; third to Sue Noonan’s Peach Pie; and fourth to Christine Olibas’s Peach Custard. First place received a trophy, a handcrafted ribbon by local artist Diane McNulty, and a prize basket. Second- through fourth-place winners also received handcrafted ribbons and prize baskets, the awards honoring both skill and community pride.

Thanks to The Community Voice for letting us use this photo of Lynda Hopkins getting dunked in the dunk tank. She may have been the only one there who was not broiling hot. Photo by Robert Graves.
New this year was a Dunk Tank. Diane Helman took tickets for the event which quickly became a crowd favorite. Local leaders, including County Supervisor Lynda Hopkins and Municipal Advisory Committee members Thai Hilton and Lonnie Lazar, all proved to be good sports, plunging repeatedly to the delight of attendees. “A good time was had by all,” said Wendy Flowers, President of the Chamber of Commerce.
Kids had their share of fun too. When they weren’t at the Pie Walk, Tony Marchetti wowed young ones with a giant bubble maker, while the Kids’ Corner, directed by Crista Mone, kept hands busy with crafts and imaginations sparked. Together with the pies and music, these activities turned the day into a true family festival.
The setting itself is part of the story. Forestville’s 4.2-acre Downtown Oaks Park was once threatened by development but was preserved in 2013 thanks to a partnership between the FPA, local donors, and Sonoma County’s Agricultural Preservation & Open Space District. Today, the oak woodland and meadow remain open for the public to enjoy, complete with a plaza, event grounds, and the West County Trailhead.
Pie in the Park is more than a festival of pies, it’s a celebration of community, history, and joy. Beneath ancient oaks, neighbors shared stories, laughter, and simple pleasures. With music in the air, bubbles drifting skyward, raffle baskets brimming, triumphant bakery pie winners, and homemade pies passed hand to hand, the second annual gathering was not only as sweet as the first…it was even sweeter.